Ready for lunch?

We have a few ideas!

Central Market: Order NOW! pick up or delivery! Red Lion: Order Now! pick up or delivery!

Click Below for Catering!

Our Story

We LOVE Hoagies, Grinders and Cheesesteaks!!!

Authentic Philadelphia style sandwiches in York! Yep, you read that right! At Hefty Lefty’s we are obsessed with hoagies, grinders and cheesesteaks! In fact, “obsessed” might not be strong enough. Our mission at Hefty Lefty’s is to make you the freshest, tastiest and most creative sandwich you have ever had!!

Read More About Our Story!

Sandwich Gallery

Check out our full sandwich menu!

What Our Customers Are Saying:

“Stopped here for the first time and got “The Flying Pig” hefty. They certainly don’t skimp on the meats as I could barely finish it. Everything had amazing flavor and good price.”

- Dylan M.

“Stopped by for the first time (finally) over the weekend, the hoagie was awesome! The roll was as good as they get, definitely recommend!”

- Stephen E.

“Hefty Lefty’s never disappoints! Their hoagies are the absolute best! We are so glad that we discovered this gem. Amazing staff, quality control, and ingredients!”

- Melissa R.

Hefty Lefty’s Hoagies and Grinders

Central Market, 34 West Philadelphia Street

York, PA 17401

Email mark.millek@heftyleftys.com

Central Market Location:

Tuesday - Saturday: 10 am - 2 pm

Sunday and Monday: Closed

Franklin Street Social Location:

Tuesday - Sunday: 11 am - 8 pm

Monday: Closed

Join Our Email List!

Do you want to receive updates, news, and coupons from Hefty Lefty’s Hoagies and Grinders? Use the button below to sign up for our email list!

In house shaved ribeye with Cooper Sharp Cheese and grilled onions. We like to call it The Classic!

Ready to order for your crew?

Order Now!