Hefty Lefty's
  • Home
  • Our Story
  • Our Sandwiches
  • Catering
  • Order Online

What Makes Our Sandwiches Special?

It has to be perfect! No detail is too small!

Every great sandwich starts with the roll.  Our rolls are delivered everyday from The Corropolese Italian Bakery. Corropolese has been recognized as the Best of Philly numerous times.  We use only the finest meats and cheeses from brands like Citterio, Thumanns, BelGioioso and Grande Cheese.  Our cheesesteaks are made with thin sliced ribeye cut daily in house.  We shop our local farmers market to secure only the freshest produce. We are up early every morning to prep ingredients for the day.  The payoff comes in stacking all of these ingredients in our unique tuck and roll combination to create one of the greatest sandwiches you will ever eat.

Menu Options

Hoagies

Grinders

Cheesesteaks

curly  Fries

Hoagies

Stuffed sandwiches with freshly cuts meats and crisp veggies served on rolls delivered daily from the Corropolese Italian Bakery.

  • Available in three sizes:                                          4” Hardy,   6” Husky,   9” Hefty
  • The best hoagie I’ve ever had. Friendly folks, clean little spot. They pile on the meats and toppings. This is worth going out of your way for!!  - Ethan S.

Grinders

Oven toasted sandwiches with fresh cut meats, crisp veggies and heaped with a quarter pound of melted mozzarella cheese on a seeded Italian roll from the Corropolese Italian Bakery.

  • Available in one size: 6”
  • Best sandwich (Balboa Grinder) I’ve ever had! and THAT BREAD! - Laura G.

Cheesesteaks

Fresh shaved ribeye with grilled onions and cheese served on a roll from the Corropolese Italian Bakery.

  • Available in two sizes:                                     Husky: 8”   Hefty 12”
  • Four varieties of Cheesesteaks:                   The Classic, The O.C., The Chicolini, The Razors Edge
  • Just had a cheesesteak delivered, OMG it was so good!!! - Steve M.

Fresh Cut Curly Fries

Fresh Cut Curly Fries

  • Available in three sizes:                                        small, medium, large
  • Everything was great. Best curly fries I ever had. - Lewis T.

Best sub I ever had, no lies. I DoorDashed this and was so pleasantly surprised! Will be back! - Lori F.

What are you waiting for?

Order Now! pick up or delivery!

Contact

Hefty Lefty’s Hoagies and Grinders
Central Market, 34 West Philadelphia Street
York, PA 17401
Email mark.millek@heftyleftys.com

Hours

Central Market Location:

Tuesday - Saturday: 10 am - 2 pm

Sunday and Monday: Closed

Franklin Street Social Location:

Tuesday - Saturday: 11 am - 8 pm

Sunday: 12 pm - 8 pm

Monday: Closed

Connect

© 2025 Hefty Lefty’s Powered by Jottful